Harrison Butker or Jake Elliott: Toss-Up — Week 1 Start/Sit Verdict

Butker's stalls vs. Elliott's blowout math: two paths to the same 8.5

Butker banks his floor on inefficiency — his offense stalls in the red zone more than twice as often as Philadelphia's, which means more trips to the fringe of field-goal range instead of the end zone, and he's converting at a much higher clip when those chances come. Elliott's case is the opposite: Philadelphia scores so often and is favored by so much that even with fewer stalls, the sheer number of possessions and the extra-point volume that comes with a heavy favorite role keeps his floor competitive. Both sit at K12/K13 with identical point projections, and neither carries any red flag on availability. The real difference is which flavor of volume you trust more — accuracy-backed stalls or blowout-game garbage-time trips.

What flips it: A short week weather downgrade at either open-roof site would swing this toward whichever kicker's offense still finds itself stalling short of the end zone.

AI editor

Harrison Butker

K13KCvs DEN

8.58.58.5 Projected Points

Start· medium

Jake Elliott

K12PHIvs WSH

8.58.58.5 Projected Points

Start· medium

Why Harrison Butker

Start· medium

Veteran starting kicker with big-leg range. Proven under postseason pressure.

K10 with 8.5 projected, 87% accuracy and 1.5 red-zone stalls per game in a 22.5-point offense — enough volume to start in 12-team.

Nearly 9-in-10 accuracy this season means the tries he does get are more likely to actually go through.
A red-zone stall rate almost double Philadelphia's gives him more look at makeable kicks instead of touchdowns eating the drive.

The call

Butker projects for 8.5 points at K10, which is above the replacement line in a 12-team league where only 12 kickers start.
Kansas City's implied total of 22.5 plus 1.5 red-zone stalls per game supports the 2.1 projected attempts and 2.1 extra points — his floor comes from a functional offense that also settles for field goals.
He's the locked-in PK1 with no injury designation, hitting 87% (33/38) with five 50-plus makes and a 59-yard long, so range isn't a limiter in a tight 2.5-point game.
Only real risk is the open roof with no forecast yet — heavy wind or precipitation against Denver would push this back toward a coin flip.

Latest on Butker

Seattle Seahawks vs. Kansas City Chiefs Game Highlights

ESPN · Aug 28, 2026

Reported by the sources listed — not independently verified.

Why Jake Elliott

Start· medium

Veteran starting K with big-leg range. Proven in high-leverage postseason kicks.

26.0 implied team total and a 5.5-point favorite role give Elliott a 3.0-XP floor plus 1.9 FG tries — enough volume despite the K20 tag.

Playing as a much bigger favorite in a higher-scoring offense means more total possessions and extra-point tries to fall back on.
Even with fewer red-zone stalls, a 26-point implied total keeps the door open for more field-goal tries if drives bog down inside the 10.

The call

Philadelphia's 26.0 implied total is the key input: 3.0 projected extra points give Elliott a floor most K20-ranked kickers don't have, and 1.9 attempts add the upside.
Only 0.8 red-zone stalls per game means this offense finishes drives rather than settling for field goals — that caps attempt volume but converts into the XP floor instead.
Risk factors are real: 74% accuracy (20/27) is unimpressive and the K20 consensus rank says the market sees him as a fringe starter, so a shootout that stalls could leave 5-6 points.
He's locked in as PK1 with no injury designation, and the open roof has no forecast yet — recheck weather before locking, since wind is the one thing that would flip this to a sit.

Head-to-head stats

Metric	Harrison Butker	Jake Elliott
Projected points	8.58.58.5	8.58.58.5
Consensus rank	K13	K12
Projected FG attempts	2.1	1.9
Red-zone stalls / game	1.5(2025)	0.8(2025)
Implied total · spread	22.5-2.5	26.0-5.5
Field-goal %	86.8%(2025)	74.1%(2025)
Depth chart	K1	K1
Start/Sit record	0–0+1 toss-up	—